Search
Warm neutral open-plan kitchen and living area in a newer single-story home, overlooking a small private backyard in autumn.

What Each Saddlewood Builder's Price Buys in West Oakdale

Two new homes on Woodhouse Lane show the problem. At 2817 Woodhouse Lane, D.R. Horton is asking $520,990 for a one-story, three-bedroom Madrone of 1,588 square feet. A few doors away at 2813 Woodhouse Lane, a two-story, four-bedroom Reyes of 1,615 square feet is listed at $459,490, down from $476,490. That is about the same amount of house from the same builder in the same subdivision, and the prices are $61,500 apart.

That gap is what you need to understand before you compare Saddlewood with a resale home in town, or with new construction in Riverbank or Modesto. Three builders are selling side by side in this west Oakdale master plan, and their price ranges overlap. The builder's name tells you less about the price than the plan does. Stairs, size and what comes standard move the number more. If you're shopping for new homes in Oakdale this fall, the useful comparison is plan against plan.

One Master Plan, Three Price Sheets

Saddlewood sits on Oakdale's west side, off Crane Road, north of Highway 108 and West F Street. It is the first project built under the Crane Crossing Specific Plan. Three builders are selling there now.

D.R. Horton's Monarch at Saddlewood has its sales office at 2941 Woodhouse Lane. It has four one- and two-story plans from 1,588 to 1,895 square feet, with quartz counters, shaker-style cabinets and Whirlpool stainless appliances. Florsheim Homes' Saddlewood is a 35-home neighborhood at 8112 Crane Road, with models at Timberwood Drive and Dapple Road. Every plan there is two-story. Legacy Homes' Tanner Ranch sells from 2914 Woodhouse Lane. It has four single- and two-story plans of roughly 1,680 to 2,542 square feet, on lots that mostly run 5,000 to 6,000 square feet.

Here is every plan whose price and size the builders published this fall, sorted by price per square foot.

Builder and plan Stories Sq. ft. Base price Approx. per sq. ft.
D.R. Horton Madrone 1 1,588 in the $526s $331
Legacy Residence 1680 not specified 1,680 $539,990 $321
Florsheim Pinnacle 2 1,637 $499,000 $305
D.R. Horton Reyes 2 1,615 in the $476s $295
Florsheim Skyline 2 1,807 to 1,823 $521,000 $288
D.R. Horton Palisade 2 1,858 in the $526s $283
D.R. Horton Sierra 2 1,895 in the $531s $280
Legacy Residence 2121 not specified 2,121 $589,990 $278
Legacy Residence 2169 not specified 2,169 $589,990 $272
Florsheim Vantage 2 2,039 to 2,207 $550,000 $270
Legacy Residence 2542 not specified 2,542 $629,990 $248

D.R. Horton's plan prices are rounded from its "starting in the" labels. Florsheim's base prices come from its Saddlewood page, dated October 15, 2026, and where Florsheim gives a size range, the per-foot figure uses the smaller size. Legacy's plan prices come from a new-home listing that was verified with the builder on October 26, 2026.

Sorted this way, the three builders are mixed together. Each builder's smallest plan falls between $305 and $331 a square foot. Each builder's largest plan falls between $248 and $280.

The Entry Price Buys the Most Expensive Square Feet

Every builder in Saddlewood prices added space for less than the space in its smallest plan. Florsheim's Pinnacle and Vantage show it. The smallest Vantage is 402 square feet larger than the Pinnacle and costs $51,000 more, about $127 for each added square foot, compared with about $305 a foot for the Pinnacle itself. Legacy's price sheet shows it too. The 2121 and the 2169 have the same base price, $589,990, so the extra 48 square feet in the larger plan cost nothing on paper.

For a buyer, this makes the lowest sticker price and the best value two separate questions. If your budget tops out near $500,000, the lowest prices in Saddlewood are in the smaller plans. If you can stretch about $50,000, the price per square foot drops quickly as you move up in size.

The One-Story Premium Is Visible on Woodhouse Lane

D.R. Horton's plan list makes the single-story cost easy to see. The Madrone is one story and 1,588 square feet. The Palisade is two stories and 1,858 square feet. Both start in the $526s. At the same builder and the same starting price, the two-story has 270 more square feet.

The same premium shows up in the gap between 2817 and 2813 Woodhouse Lane. Florsheim builds only two-story plans in Saddlewood. Buyers who need everything on one level are choosing among D.R. Horton's Madrone and whichever of Legacy's plans are single-story. In both cases they pay more per foot than buyers who can take stairs.

What Comes With a Florsheim Price

Florsheim's Pinnacle starts at $499,000, about $22,500 above D.R. Horton's Reyes, which is roughly the same size. Florsheim's answer is its standard feature list. Every plan page describes "ALL electric homes powered by owned solar (and MID)," along with high-efficiency heating and air, an electric water heater and a weather-sensing irrigation timer. The standard exterior includes concrete tile roofing, boxed soffits, full rain gutters, drought-tolerant front landscaping with automatic irrigation, and rear and side fencing with a gate.

In July 2026, Florsheim published a comparison flyer for Saddlewood that sets its standard features against those of unnamed "other builders." The flyer lists items such as "buyer-owned solar at no additional cost" and a "1 ⅛″ solid plywood subfloor." It also says that prices exclude options, upgrades, elevation premiums and lot premiums. Legacy treats solar differently. It lists a solar lease or purchase as available, along with front landscaping with automatic irrigation and rear-yard fencing.

The practical step is to put solar, landscaping, fencing and appliances on the same line for every home you tour. Florsheim's standard kitchen list names a GE stainless range, microwave and dishwasher, with the refrigerator space pre-plumbed for an icemaker. Once those items are on equal footing, a $20,000 difference on the base price can shrink or grow.

How Fast Saddlewood Is Selling

Florsheim's third-quarter 2026 update, dated September 1, reported 20 homes sold since the Saddlewood preview opening, out of a neighborhood of 35. At D.R. Horton, three Monarch homes were listed for sale this fall, and two of them were priced below their plan's base. The Reyes at 2813 Woodhouse Lane was cut by $17,000, to $459,490. The Madrone at 2817 is listed at $520,990, compared with a plan price in the $526s. The third, a Palisade at 2806 Woodhouse Lane, is listed at $529,490.

The county numbers give these prices some context. The California Association of Realtors reported a Stanislaus County median sale price for existing single-family homes of $491,800 in September 2026, up 3.5% from $475,000 in September 2025. The same C.A.R. release put September 2026 unsold inventory at 3.6 months and median time on market at 28.5 days. So D.R. Horton's reduced Reyes is priced below the county's typical resale home, and every Legacy plan is priced above it. Saddlewood spans the county median, with brand-new construction on both sides of it.

Saddlewood Is the First Phase of a Long Plan

Today's Saddlewood prices are early prices in a much larger area. Oakdale adopted the Crane Crossing Specific Plan, covering 262.5 gross acres along the city's northwestern edge, on March 3, 2014. Eleven years later, on February 12, 2025, the City Council voted 3-0 to approve Saddlewood's final map and improvement agreement, as Citizen Portal reported.

The plan also lays out what is supposed to grow around the first homes. It calls for four parks totaling 13.81 acres, including an 8.63-acre neighborhood park and a 3.68-acre bluff park. It also calls for an open-space corridor along an Oakdale Irrigation District easement, with a planned bike path linking some of the parks to Crane Road. Across town, the City Council approved amendments to the roughly 297-acre Sierra Pointe Specific Plan on Oakdale's southeast side in March 2025, according to the Oakdale Leader. Its annexation was still headed to Stanislaus LAFCO. LAFCO's planning document estimates Sierra Pointe could add up to 901 homes at full buildout.

If you buy in Saddlewood now, you may resell years from now in a part of town with many more new homes around yours.

A Few Questions Worth Asking at Each Sales Office

Should I compare the plan price or the move-in-ready price?

Compare both. On D.R. Horton's Monarch page this fall, two of the three available homes were listed below their plan's base price, and one was listed above it. A finished home lets you skip the choices and the wait, but the lot and elevation are already set.

What recurring costs should go on my comparison sheet?

Ask each builder for its written disclosures on HOA dues and any special tax or assessment on the lot, and put those figures next to the price. Oakdale has Community Facilities Districts listed on the city's CFD page. In a past post, we looked at how Modesto's newer subdivisions add a line item that the price alone doesn't show. If you're adding these costs to a budget, treat this as general information rather than legal, tax or financial advice, and confirm the figures for your own lot with the right professional. Our guide to closing costs in Oakdale covers what comes due at signing.

How does Saddlewood compare with an older Oakdale home of the same size?

A resale home has no plan menu, and its price reflects the lot, the age of the house and the street. Our Oakdale neighborhood page is the place to start that comparison. If you own a home in town and want to know where it sits next to Saddlewood's per-square-foot prices, an instant valuation gives you a first number to work with.

If you're weighing a Saddlewood plan against a resale home elsewhere in Oakdale, Lisa Vandermeer can help you compare the per-square-foot math and the standard features before you sign anything. Schedule a Free Consultation and bring the price sheets you've collected.

Work With Lisa

Contact Lisa today to learn more about her unique approach to real estate and how she can help you get the results you deserve.

Follow Me on Instagram